What Are Sanctions in a Divorce Case?
By Jim Thomas
Sanctions during a divorce proceeding are penalties for bad behavior by a spouse or his attorney during a divorce. Sanctions can be imposed by a family law judge and are governed by state law. Sanctions, in the form of monetary damages, may be assessed if one party to a divorce acts in a manner that unreasonably delays the settlement of the case. For example, you can be compelled to pay the attorney fees of your soon-to-be ex-spouse, fined a large amount of money or denied an equitable share of the assets of the marriage.
Family law courts ask the parties to cooperate to resolve divorces, especially when the couple has children. So the nature and length of a spouse's uncooperative behavior are factors in determining if sanctions are appropriate. Sanctions tend to be imposed if you or your spouse try to hide assets that must be disclosed during a divorce case, refuse to comply with an order of the court or clog up the court system with frivolous complaints or motions. In a recent New York case, an ex-wife who continued to file new claims and motions over a seven-year period and ignored court orders to stop was sanctioned and fined more than $60,000.
Types of Penalties
Family law courts have a range of penalties they can impose for unacceptable conduct. Sometimes the court bases the amount of the penalty on the additional amount in attorney fees the other side incurred because of the bad behavior. Sometimes a judge punishes a spouse who hides assets by negating her customary right to a split of those assets. For example, in a California case, a woman who did not disclose winning more than $1 million in a lottery was ordered to pay the entire amount to her ex-husband, a penalty that exceeded $500,000 - the amount that would've been his community property share of the winnings had she properly disclosed the winnings during their divorce proceedings.
If a court imposes sanctions on your spouse or ex-spouse, make sure you have met all of your legal obligations or you run the risk of losing the monetary penalty on appeal. For example, an appeals court in California denied a $200,000 sanction award to a spouse after finding she had not met all of her disclosure requirements in addition to having played a role in dragging out the divorce and increasing the level of hostility between the parties.
If you hire an attorney to represent you, make sure his behavior doesn't result in sanctions against you. Although family law cases often become contentious and hostile, they are not supposed to be overly adversarial. All parties in a divorce, including attorneys, are expected to foster cooperation and strive to reach a settlement that protects the best interests of the children of the marriage. In a recent California case, when an attorney wrote letters stating the opposing attorney was dishonest and lacked integrity, his client was sanctioned and ordered to pay a $100,000 penalty and more than $300,000 in attorney fees.
- DivorceSource.com: Sanctions for Discovery Violations
- The Hammers & Baltazar Blog: Client Sanctioned for Her Arrogant Attorney's Rude, Condescending and Unprofessional Letters
- Metropolitan News-Enterprise: Court Tosses $200,000 Sanctions Order in Divorce Case
- Roy M. Doppelt and Associates: Omitted Property Items
- Fox & Rothchild: What Happens When an Order is Violated? Can a Court Impose Sanctions?
- Divorce: New York: Sanctions and Fees Totaling $60,000 Imposed Against Ex-Wife; Divorce Litigation Often Keeps Going, and Going, and Going...
Jim Thomas has been a freelance writer since 1978. He wrote a book about professional golfers and has written magazine articles about sports, politics, legal issues, travel and business for national and Northwest publications. He received a Juris Doctor from Duke Law School and a Bachelor of Science in political science from Whitman College.